India CSR Network
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Register
SUBSCRIBE
  • Home
  • CSR
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Environment
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Health
    • Skill Development
    • No Poverty
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Articles
  • Interviews
  • Events
  • BOOKS
  • More
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Case Studies
    • Knowledge
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Philanthropy
    • Sports
    • Gaming
  • Prime
  • Home
  • CSR
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Environment
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Health
    • Skill Development
    • No Poverty
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Articles
  • Interviews
  • Events
  • BOOKS
  • More
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Case Studies
    • Knowledge
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Philanthropy
    • Sports
    • Gaming
  • Prime
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
India CSR Network
No Result
View All Result
Home More

Should private sector firms be subject to RTI & CAG? by Vinayak Chatterjee

by India CSR Network
11 years ago
in More

By Vinayak Chatterjee

In principle, private companies are, and must be, answerable to their shareholders and not the general public. It is shareholders who should be monitoring the way business is run and capital utilised. The functioning of the boards of companies in a thoroughly professional manner is thus the real need.

Citizen’s concerns on legal and statutory compliances are well addressed through the government’s multifarious departments and authorities which have all kinds of powers for detailed oversight into private sector functioning. Some would argue that there is actually excess surveillance of multiple aspects ranging from pollution and labour to insider-trading and boilers.

On the issue of governance, there are again a plethora of institutions, from sector regulators to auditors to committees of boards, who are supposed to keep track of private sector companies and their governance standards. In fact, we are constantly adding new compliance requirements, from other backward class quotas to corporate social responsibility.

Crucially, private sector companies operate in a competitive environment. All the data regarding various facets of the business are thus extremely sensitive to being made available to competitors. Thus, an RTI petition asking for specific data could well be ill-intentioned and counter-productive in a milieu where business confidentiality is the established paradigm.

As we debate this issue about private sector companies, it is also pertinent to ask, “What is a private sector company today?” About 10-15% of private sector output comes from large corporations. The rest comes from a humongous number of small and medium enterprises.

And we are not talking about factories and workshops alone. We are talking about services and even those businesses running under the Shops and Establishment Act. Most of them are in the unorganised sector and do not operate in corporate formats. Is not all of this private sector? Even if people did one RTI for every 100 companies, the sheer numbers would be overwhelming! And to what purpose?

In today’s world of blurred and inter-meshing capital markets, the distinction between private and public sector is getting more and more diffused. In today’s world of blurred and inter-meshing capital markets, the distinction between private and public sector is getting more and more diffused. There are a range of investors in a large private sector company, from public institutional investors, to sovereign wealth funds.

PC Chidambaram, when he was the finance minister, at a Larsen & Toubro function lauded the company for being a unique constituent of the “national sector”, neither private nor public! When you look at this kind of capital structuring, it becomes very difficult to define what is public and what is private.

CSRBooks.com CSRBooks.com CSRBooks.com

The accepted definition anyway is that a company where the private sector shareholding is greater than 51% is “private” and outside the ambit of inspections and audits by governmental bodies. Clearly, the grey area is public-private partnerships (PPP) today. Most PPPs technically fall under the ambit of private sector.

In its foreword to the document, ‘Public Auditing Guidelines for PPP Projects’, the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) argued that PPP requires official auditing. Critics of CAG would point out that it is a 150-year-old institution with roughly 50,000 officers and staff that carry out about 60,000 audits every year; and that it is already creaking and over-burdened.

The executive and legislative arms of the government, including the Public Accounts Committee and the Committee on Public Undertakings, are notorious for slothful responses and tardy reaction to CAG reports. Thus, adding PPPs to the list of CAG tasks is quite meaningless. However, in recent history, most would agree that CAG has been able to significantly make a difference in probity in public life.

My submission is that in the normal course of business, PPPs should not be subjected to CAG monitoring or RTI. However, in specific cases when there are issues concerning ‘public good’, government should specifically authorise CAG to investigate.

(The author is chairman, Feedback Ventures, the country’s leading infrastructure consultancy)

(The Article first published in Economic Times)

ShareTweetPin

India CSR Network

India CSR is the largest tech-led platform for information on CSR and sustainability in India offering diverse content across multisectoral issues. It covers Sustainable Development, Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), Sustainability, and related issues in India. Founded in 2009, the organisation aspires to become a globally admired media that offers valuable information to its readers through responsible reporting. To enjoy the premium content, we invite you to subscribe it.

Related Posts

Union Budget 2022: Tax Rebates in Budget for Realty Vital for Salaried Class
More

Union Budget 2022: Tax Rebates in Budget for Realty Vital for Salaried Class

January 19, 2022
India’s Veteran journalist Vinod Dua passes away
More

India’s Veteran journalist Vinod Dua passes away

December 5, 2021
Meet a NGO Leader who digs up dirt to set right system
More

Meet a NGO Leader who digs up dirt to set right system

August 10, 2021
More

Republic or Democratic?

January 22, 2021
Brand Identity of India CSR Network
CSR

Nomination invited for India CSR Professional of the Year Awards

August 4, 2021
More

Value of Books in Life

August 4, 2021
More

Google generates its 83% of revenues from the display of ads

August 4, 2021
More

Reliance Foundation Hospital rewarding medical staff with extra pay

August 4, 2021
CSR

Covid-19: ITC’s Paperboards and Specialty Paper Business lend its support to the needy in Telangana

August 4, 2021

Discussion about this post

Popular Stories

  • Lupin Terminates 300 Staff

    Lupin Terminates 300 Staff

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • What is liberalization?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 7 Reasons Why Smartphone Can Make Your Life Easier

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • QNET CSR Arm Supports Electrification Project to light up the lives of 470 villagers in Meghalaya

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • MCA amends Schedule III of Companies Act on disclosure norms in financial statements and Details of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
India CSR Network

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Partnership
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Subscribe

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • CSR
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Environment
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Health
    • Skill Development
    • No Poverty
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Articles
  • Interviews
  • Events
  • BOOKS
  • More
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Case Studies
    • Knowledge
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Philanthropy
    • Sports
    • Gaming
  • Prime
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Sign Up with Facebook
Sign Up with Google
Sign Up with Linked In
OR

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In