• India CSR Awards 2025
  • Guest Posts
Wednesday, July 9, 2025
  • Login
India CSR
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
        • Festivals
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
        • Festivals
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers
No Result
View All Result
India CSR
No Result
View All Result
Home More

Punishment and Deterrence By V S Mahesh

India CSR by India CSR
November 4, 2012
in More
Reading Time: 4 mins read
1
VIEWS
Share Share Share Share

Companies must be strict about employee crimes, or else they risk losing their customers’ trust

 By V S Mahesh

One of the fastest growing sectors, and the key for a country to become an economic powerhouse, is that of professional services firms (PSFs). Financial services, IT services and their advisors – management consulting firms like Goldman Sachs and McKinsey – are major PSFs and, therefore, naturally in the limelight. It is for this reason that Rajat Gupta’s crime of insider trading, conviction and punishment have drawn the kind of publicity they have received.

India CSRSadly, subjective issues – such as Mr Gupta’s personal history, the Indian roots of both the prosecutor and Mr Gupta, appeals from celebrities like Bill Gates and Kofi Annan for leniency in his punishment, and the court-room drama – have obfuscated what should have been the core issues: a relentless prosecutor proved that a crime had been committed, a very difficult task given the nature of insider trading. The judgment of a crime ought to focus only on the act and not on the perpetrator of crime. The objective of punishment is to deter others from falling into similar temptations of crossing the line.

One is saddened by the fall from grace of one more “good man” who has contributed a great deal to building educational and other socially important organisations. But that is no reason to avoid dealing with the core issues at hand. Rather than get enmeshed once again – like many before me in the past weeks – in the subjective aspects of the issue, let me dwell on the general problem of using punishment as a deterrent. For this purpose, I have chosen examples from easier-to-understand perspectives.

Those readers who were part of corporate India in the 1980s will remember how powerful trade unions had become by then, partly because of judgments by pro-labour courts that had made labour leaders feel that they could get away with all sorts of crimes. A senior human-resources executive I know personally was actually asked by his top management to withdraw his complaint against a union leader who had slapped a manager in his presence. When the HR manager refused to do so, he – and not the union leader – was shown the door.

It was during that time that I was part of a team in the Taj Group of Hotels that dealt with the growing menace of theft — of not only hotel property, but also hotel guests’ personal belongings. In our small world, the problem of guests’ belongings being stolen was a truly major issue, just as the failure to respect and preserve the trust of investors is in the financial services industry.

We began our crusade through a series of communications to all employees emphasising that there would be no mercy whatsoever in meting out the punishment of dismissal for those who were found guilty of the crime of theft. We had to establish in the minds of all employees that we would be fair in conducting enquiries and even-handed in our punishments, irrespective of the rank or power of the wrong-doer. Our unions took a long time to understand the firmness of our new resolve, given the company’s previous record of leniency. It took several dismissals before the message got through. Union general secretaries who had enjoyed enormous power earlier were subjected to the same rule as the rest. We withstood strikes, sabotage and negative publicity — with effigies of top management being burnt in full view of guests and the public. We paid a high price, but felt it was worth it.

To restate the point, our single objective was to establish in the minds of all employees that no leniency would be considered for anyone convicted of theft — irrespective of the power or pomp they had enjoyed prior to being found out. We succeeded. Theft was literally eradicated, and we tackled in the same manner several other discipline-related issues — for example, unauthorised absenteeism crashed from 10 per cent to less than two per cent. Punishment as a deterrent certainly worked.

It was not emotionally easy to implement such a policy. Let me give the profiles of two people we had to dismiss. A young management trainee from a premier institute was dismissed because he had “inadvertently” – as he claimed – carried in his pocket a hotel matchbox and ballpoint pen. A head waiter with a 40-year unblemished record, and whose son had been employed in a managerial capacity, was forced to resign after it was found that he tried to take out hotel soaps and shampoos worth Rs 30. As the executive with the final authority to approve their dismissals, I had to harden my heart to meet the objective of establishing in the minds of all employees that once proven, the perpetrator, whoever he may be, of theft, however small, had nowhere else to go but out.

Research findings have clearly established that customers’ choice of a financial service institution is critically dependent on how much they can “trust” the organisation to place customers’ interests above the organisation’s. Deliberate failure to maintain that trust is indeed a very serious crime — to the customer and to the organisation. The seriousness is not lessened – but actually heightened – if the one who crossed the line was a director on the board.

Here are three questions for the reader to ponder over. First, if the worst punishment for the once-powerful people found guilty were imprisonment in what T N Ninan dubbed “Club Fed” in his column last Saturday – so-called jails that are actually luxurious places with all the comforts – would it serve as an adequate deterrent for potential wrongdoers? Second, in India, where justice is most often delayed and denied, and perpetrators of crimes return to pursue active roles with greater powers after the shortest possible absence from the public eye, can we afford not to use punishment as a serious deterrent in those rare cases where criminal acts are indeed proven in a court of law? Third, if TV channels and newspapers carried images and reports of the once-high and mighty serving out rigorous imprisonment sentences for crimes committed by them – sharing cells with other criminals and breaking rocks – would that not serve as a strong deterrent for “wannabe” wrongdoers?

The writer, a former corporate executive, was the founder-director of the Centre for Service Management at the University of Buckingham, and is now MD of Chennai-based VSM Consulting Services. He can be reached at mahesh@vsmahesh.com 

(Business Standard)

Photo: Employee is the Resources for Growth

IndiaCSR Whatsapp Channel

India CSR offers strategic corporate outreach opportunities to amplify your brand’s CSR, Sustainability, and ESG success stories.

📩 Contact us at: biz@indiacsr.in

Let’s collaborate to amplify your brand’s impact in the CSR and ESG ecosystem.

India CSR

India CSR

India CSR is the largest media on CSR and sustainability offering diverse content across multisectoral issues on business responsibility. It covers Sustainable Development, Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), Sustainability, and related issues in India. Founded in 2009, the organisation aspires to become a globally admired media that offers valuable information to its readers through responsible reporting.

Related Posts

India’s Veteran journalist Vinod Dua passes away
More

India’s Veteran journalist Vinod Dua passes away

4 years ago
374
India CSR
More

Republic or Democratic?

4 years ago
280
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

How can we conserve water amidst the Coronavirus crisis?

5 years ago
42
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Toyota Kirloskar Motor temporarily halts production at its Plant in Bidadi, Karnataka

5 years ago
57
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Govt. seeks public comments on Corporate Social Responsibility Policy (CSR) Amendment Rules, 2020

5 years ago
79
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Govt to amend CSR rules under companies law, invites public comments

5 years ago
57
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

MCA sanctions Prosecution in 366 cases given in violation of CSR Provisions

5 years ago
87
More

Schindler India launches an additional employee assistance program

5 years ago
32
More

NMDC Committed to fight COVID 19 for a safe and healthy India

5 years ago
12
Load More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

India CSR Awards India CSR Awards India CSR Awards
ADVERTISEMENT

LATEST NEWS

CSR: Kotak Securities’ Kona Kona Shiksha Empowers 73,000+ Youth in FY25

Aadhar Housing Finance Transfers Rs 4.73 Crore to Unspent CSR Account for FY25

What Is The Fastest Way To Withdraw Money From Online Casino Sites?

Why Sharing Images of Tragedy Violates Human Dignity and Rights

Himachal Pradesh Mandates Chief Minister’s Approval for CSR Fund Proposals

हिमाचल प्रदेश में सीएसआर फंड पर नई सख्ती: अब मुख्यमंत्री की मंजूरी जरूरी

HZL HZL HZL
ADVERTISEMENT

TOP NEWS

Alyssa Carson: 10 Interesting Facts Every Girl Must Know

CSR: Ambuja Cements Transforms Rural Youth Lives through Skill Training in Chandrapur

This CSR Foundation Serves 20 Lakh Meals in Odisha

Dr. Elie Organics Leads the Way: CSR Initiative Powers Lonikand, Pune Biodiversity Park Inauguration For Love, Peace and Humanity

CSR: Kotak Securities’ Kona Kona Shiksha Empowers 73,000+ Youth in FY25

हिन्दुस्तान जिंक ने लैंग्वेज गाइड बुक लांच कर कार्यस्थल समावेशन में नए मानक स्थापित किए

Load More

Advertisement

Image Slider
content writing services Guest Post Top 5 Reasons to have Sponsored Posts at India CSR – India’s Largest CSR Media stem learning R2V2 Technologies Private Limited

Interviews

Himanshu Nivsarkar, Senior Executive Vice President and Head of CSR & ESG at Kotak Mahindra Bank
Interviews

Driving Sustainable Impact: An Interview with Himanshu Nivsarkar, Kotak Mahindra Bank

by India CSR
May 22, 2025
147

By Rusen Kumar NEW DELHI (India CSR): Himanshu Nivsarkar, Senior Executive Vice President and Head of CSR & ESG at Kotak...

Read moreDetails
Balamurugan Thevar, CSR Head at Shriram Finance

Empowering Women Drivers: An Interview with Balamurugan Thevar, CSR Head at Shriram Finance

May 20, 2025
220
N E Sridhar, the Chief Sustainability Officer at Titan Company Ltd.

Empowering Rural Craft Entrepreneurs: An Interview with N E Sridhar, Titan Company

May 15, 2025
103
Geetaj Channana, the Head of Corporate Strategy at Vivo India

Empowering Young Innovators Across India: An Interview with Geetaj Channana, the Head of Corporate Strategy at Vivo India

April 25, 2025
58
Load More
Facebook Twitter Youtube LinkedIn Instagram
India CSR Logo

India CSR is the largest tech-led platform for information on CSR and sustainability in India offering diverse content across multisectoral issues. It covers Sustainable Development, Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), Sustainability, and related issues in India. Founded in 2009, the organisation aspires to become a globally admired media that offers valuable information to its readers through responsible reporting. To enjoy the premium services, we invite you to partner with us.

Follow us on social media:


Dear Valued Reader

India CSR is a free media platform that provides up-to-date information on CSR, Sustainability, ESG, and SDGs. They need reader support to continue delivering honest news. Donations of any amount are appreciated.

Help save India CSR.

Donate Now

donate at indiacsr

  • About India CSR
  • Team
  • India CSR Awards 2025
  • Partnership
  • Guest Posts
  • Services
  • Content Writing Services
  • Business Information
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Donate

Copyright © 2025 - India CSR | All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers

Copyright © 2025 - India CSR | All Rights Reserved

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.