• India CSR Awards 2025
  • Guest Posts
Thursday, July 17, 2025
  • Login
India CSR
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
        • Festivals
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
        • Festivals
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers
No Result
View All Result
India CSR
No Result
View All Result
Home More

Mandatory Spending on CSR Does not fit in a Market-Driven Society

India CSR by India CSR
January 27, 2012
in More
Reading Time: 4 mins read
Share Share Share Share

By Shubhashis Gangopadhyay

India CSRThe parliamentary panel looking into the provisions of the Companies Bill wants to make it mandatory for the corporate sector to spend a portion of its profit on activities that are socially beneficial. From my reading of the discussions, the major areas of dispute are:

(a) should it be one per cent or two per cent of profit; (b) what defines the corporate sector and socially beneficial expenditure by them; and (c) should the spending be mandatory or only its disclosure be mandatory. I find all of this very amusing. Let me explain why.

First, I am surprised at why non-governmental organisations are not opposing this move at a time when they are up in arms against cash transfers of all kinds. Their argument against cash transfers is that it shows a certain degree of irresponsibility by the government; instead of physically transferring the exact resources and services that households need for a minimum quality of life, something that the government is duty-bound to provide, it is throwing cash at decision-making households and asking them to obtain these directly from the market. In other words, a government that believes in cash transfers (for instance, as substitutes for subsidised food and subsidised kerosene) is irresponsible because it is asking heads of households to take decisions on how much to spend on what. Indeed, the most common refrain is that if cash is made available to the poor, they will “drink it up”.

By the same logic, a government that asks the corporate sector to spend its profits on socially responsible activities is also highly irresponsible. After all, citizens pay taxes for governments to spend on public goods and redistribute resources. A government that asks the corporate sector to chip in and carry out these activities should also be viewed as irresponsible. It is asking the corporate sector to do something that is fundamentally the responsibility of the government.

However, those who support cash transfers can still oppose making it mandatory for corporations to undertake CSR activities. The reason for supporting cash transfers is that households are idiosyncratic, and they know better than any paternalistic third party how much of what they need. In other words, households have the knowledge and the incentives to do what is best for them — they only need the opportunity to be able to do so. In a market-driven society, purchasing power — or cash — gives them that opportunity.

Private corporations are supposed to make profits and return them to their investors. Investors, therefore, choose those projects that give them higher returns, and managers of these projects are expected to specialise in the ability to make profits. If one wants entities that specialise in social activities, investors themselves can decide how much to put directly into these activities. Why put in money for steel production because such producers make social investments? Is it not better to choose the most profit-making steel producer and then use the dividends, or the realised capital gains, to directly fund social activities? This division of labour among steel producers and those that undertake social activities is what makes both efficient and transparent.

Many would argue that CSR is good business practice. If that were so, one would have to assume that good managers know that. And, if they know, then to signal that they are good managers they would be undertaking CSR anyway, with or without the law. Indeed, they would choose a level of CSR that is in keeping with what maximises the returns from investment. For some companies that would be 5 per cent of their total expenditure, for others it could be 0.5 per cent. And, observe, I do not say “of profit”. If social activity produces an enabling environment, you want that to be more stable than profits ever are in a market society. If CSR expenditure is tied to fundamentally volatile profits, and running schools is a corporate activity, your child will have new textbooks one year and no textbooks another year!

On the other hand, there are people who feel good investing in companies that work for society. Such investors want their investment to yield a return and be used for the greater good. They are unable to undertake socially good activities by themselves, for an obvious reason: social activities, like profit-making activities, require a minimum scale of operation to be efficient, or even feasible. Companies are aggregators of resources and they will do this well, especially if it is good for their business. And, if doing good CSR attracts more resources for their business, they will shout their intentions from available rooftops.

Therefore, defining disclosure norms for CSR activities is the way to go. People must be confident that what businesses are claiming is true and regulatory institutions need to be able to monitor truth-telling by companies. Indeed, what mandatory CSR spend does is take away the ability of efficient companies to distance themselves from the inefficient ones. After all, if everyone is spending similar amounts, how will you distinguish among them? If it works for them, they should spend more than 1 per cent; if it does not, they should spend less.

The thing that bothers me the most is that supporters of mandatory CSR by the corporate sector refer to pieces exhorting corporate CSR written by business-school professors abroad. While I am willing to grant that they are smarter than we can ever be, they are also not always right. 2008 is not yet a distant memory! So, why can we not try to think for ourselves instead of relying on others to do the thinking for us?

Shubhashis Gangopadhyay: The writer is Research Director, IDF, and director of the School of Humanities and Social Sciences at SNU

(Article first published in Business Standard)

Disclaimer:  The views expressed by the author in this feature are entirely his own and do not necessarily reflect the views of INDIACSR)

IndiaCSR Whatsapp Channel

India CSR offers strategic corporate outreach opportunities to amplify your brand’s CSR, Sustainability, and ESG success stories.

📩 Contact us at: biz@indiacsr.in

Let’s collaborate to amplify your brand’s impact in the CSR and ESG ecosystem.

India CSR

India CSR

India CSR is the largest media on CSR and sustainability offering diverse content across multisectoral issues on business responsibility. It covers Sustainable Development, Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), Sustainability, and related issues in India. Founded in 2009, the organisation aspires to become a globally admired media that offers valuable information to its readers through responsible reporting.

Related Posts

India’s Veteran journalist Vinod Dua passes away
More

India’s Veteran journalist Vinod Dua passes away

4 years ago
India CSR
More

Republic or Democratic?

4 years ago
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

How can we conserve water amidst the Coronavirus crisis?

5 years ago
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Toyota Kirloskar Motor temporarily halts production at its Plant in Bidadi, Karnataka

5 years ago
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Govt. seeks public comments on Corporate Social Responsibility Policy (CSR) Amendment Rules, 2020

5 years ago
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Govt to amend CSR rules under companies law, invites public comments

5 years ago
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

MCA sanctions Prosecution in 366 cases given in violation of CSR Provisions

5 years ago
More

Schindler India launches an additional employee assistance program

5 years ago
More

NMDC Committed to fight COVID 19 for a safe and healthy India

5 years ago
Load More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

India CSR Awards India CSR Awards India CSR Awards
ADVERTISEMENT

LATEST NEWS

Hindustan Zinc Integrates AI to Optimize Zinc Production Processes

हिंदुस्तान जिंक ने जिंक उत्पादन तकनीकों को बेहतर बनाने के लिए एआई को अपनाया

CSR: Ambuja Cements and Adani Foundation Strengthen Rural Healthcare Access

Elanpro Rolls Out CSR Pilot to Train 100 Technicians Nationwide

Dalmia Bharat Foundation, Vishwa Yuvak Kendra Celebrate Youth Skills Day with AI Seminar

Bangladesh Premier League (BPL): How It Has Influenced the Development of Cricket in the Country

HZL HZL HZL
ADVERTISEMENT

TOP NEWS

Tesla’s Grand Entry into India: Mumbai Showroom to Open on July 15, 2025

छत्तीसगढ़ के गांवों को उजाड़कर रौशन होगा महाराष्ट्र

IndiGo’s Potential Order of 40 Airbus A350 Planes: A Strategic Leap in Global Aviation

RECPDCL Inks Smart Meter Deal for 33.26 Lakh Prepaid Units in Gujarat

CSR: Ambuja Cements and Adani Foundation Strengthen Rural Healthcare Access

MCA Unveils New CSR-1 e-Form to Streamline Corporate Social Responsibility in India

Load More

Advertisement

Image Slider
content writing services Guest Post Top 5 Reasons to have Sponsored Posts at India CSR – India’s Largest CSR Media stem learning R2V2 Technologies Private Limited

Interviews

Himanshu Nivsarkar, Senior Executive Vice President and Head of CSR & ESG at Kotak Mahindra Bank
Interviews

Driving Sustainable Impact: An Interview with Himanshu Nivsarkar, Kotak Mahindra Bank

by India CSR
May 22, 2025

By Rusen Kumar NEW DELHI (India CSR): Himanshu Nivsarkar, Senior Executive Vice President and Head of CSR & ESG at Kotak...

Read moreDetails
Balamurugan Thevar, CSR Head at Shriram Finance

Empowering Women Drivers: An Interview with Balamurugan Thevar, CSR Head at Shriram Finance

May 20, 2025
N E Sridhar, the Chief Sustainability Officer at Titan Company Ltd.

Empowering Rural Craft Entrepreneurs: An Interview with N E Sridhar, Titan Company

May 15, 2025
Geetaj Channana, the Head of Corporate Strategy at Vivo India

Empowering Young Innovators Across India: An Interview with Geetaj Channana, the Head of Corporate Strategy at Vivo India

April 25, 2025
Load More
Facebook Twitter Youtube LinkedIn Instagram
India CSR Logo

India CSR is the largest tech-led platform for information on CSR and sustainability in India offering diverse content across multisectoral issues. It covers Sustainable Development, Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), Sustainability, and related issues in India. Founded in 2009, the organisation aspires to become a globally admired media that offers valuable information to its readers through responsible reporting. To enjoy the premium services, we invite you to partner with us.

Follow us on social media:


Dear Valued Reader

India CSR is a free media platform that provides up-to-date information on CSR, Sustainability, ESG, and SDGs. They need reader support to continue delivering honest news. Donations of any amount are appreciated.

Help save India CSR.

Donate Now

donate at indiacsr

  • About India CSR
  • Team
  • India CSR Awards 2025
  • Partnership
  • Guest Posts
  • Services
  • Content Writing Services
  • Business Information
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Donate

Copyright © 2025 - India CSR | All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers

Copyright © 2025 - India CSR | All Rights Reserved

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.