• India CSR Awards 2025
  • Guest Posts
Wednesday, July 2, 2025
  • Login
India CSR
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
        • Festivals
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
        • Festivals
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers
No Result
View All Result
India CSR
No Result
View All Result
Home More

The creeping control that is mandatory CSR by Ravi Shanker Kapoor

India CSR by India CSR
in More
Reading Time: 3 mins read
6
VIEWS
Share Share Share Share

By Ravi Shanker Kapoor

village boy with indian flag
Village boy with indian flag

If there is one country where the worst fears of classical liberal philosophers, contemporary libertarians, and Western conservatives tend to be confirmed, it is India. The provision in the new Companies Bill to impose corporate social responsibility (CSR) on India Inc is one such exercise in dirigisme.

The attempt to make CSR mandatory is the epitome of illiberal welfarism, a thing no lover of human freedom can condone, let alone support. The first and foremost objection to the idea is that it represents the state’s brazen desire to control of one of the noblest of human instincts – philanthropy. The urge to help fellow human beings is as old as mankind. Over two-and-a-half millennia ago, Prince Siddhartha Gautam, moved by the sufferings of men and women around him, sacrificed all the pleasures and privileges that his royal status could bring to him and became Lord Buddha. He was certainly not responding to some fiat by his father to do so.

Similarly, those countless Europeans who gave up comfortable lives to serve humanity as Christian missionaries in Africa and Asia did not do so because of some government diktat. In the last century, a large number of rich youngsters in the West as well as in India became communists and socialists in the mistaken belief that their ideologies would make the world a better place. Many American tycoons have donated huge amounts to set up foundations and charities. Indian business houses have also done their bit. So, why should our government force big industry to become philanthropic?

Mandatory CSR is egregious not just because it introduces a pointless state intervention where none is needed, but also, and more so, because it attempts to control all that is personal and private to any individual – instincts, sentiments, munificence, genuine and spontaneous altruism. It enters the sacred space of the citizen and defiles its sanctity.

Khalil Gibran’s Prophet tells the people of Orphalese: “Your children are not your children.” In a similar vein, the Indian state tells businesspersons: “Your sentiments are not your sentiments. We’ll tell you what you should do with them.” Totalitarianism need not be the result of a violent revolution; the takeover of a society can also take place by way of a creeping acquisition.

This is exactly what is taking place. Our netas and babus want to tell corporate czars what should be done for the betterment of society. The very people who have messed up governance and vitiated every sphere of public life will frame rules and regulations for corporations’ philanthropic activities!

Corporate Affairs Minister Veerappa Moily said in an interview, “We have now taken a task to convince the corporate world… We have also said that disclosure is mandatory, but implementation is not mandatory.” Industry, however, has no reason to cheer because the government is unrelenting, and so is the army of professional revolutionaries. For it is the intellectual class that is responsible for a climate of opinion that helps our political masters chalk out policies to strangle business.

Thus, Moily said: “We have put in a schedule of the Bill on the activities they [corporations] should carry out. Now, we will have well-structured meetings… One meeting is with the PSUs… The next stage meeting is where we will discuss with the corporate world on what best they can do. There are as many as 300 most backward districts in the country…”

Now boardrooms will have to take a call not just on market share, corporate strategies, and financials but also the socio-economic conditions of the country. The focus has to shift from the interests of shareholders to the prospects of national development.

Numerous studies have blamed the diffusion of focus and mixing of objectives as one of the maladies afflicting public sector undertakings. The provision of mandatory CSR will surely infect the private sector with the same disease. Since the government will always be keen to tell companies “what best they can do”, politicians get an opportunity to influence and even coerce top executives to aid those non-government organisations and jholawallahs that serve political interests. Notice the preposterousness of the situation: India Inc would be forced to finance incorrigible Luddites and rabid radicals.

When rules and regulations are irrational, the sphere of discretion expands and sharp practice flourishes. It happened in the dark ages of the pre-liberalisation era; it happens today at all levels. Mandatory CSR will be a boon to the corrupt.

Politicians are not much interested in philanthropy. In the earlier years of the last decade, many successful professionals wanted to make huge contributions to their alma maters, such as the IITs and IIMs, but the government insisted that this could happen only through its own agency. It set up a fund, which had to be shut after some time because it got just Rs 1,651.

The quantum of CSR spend is not the issue; the ulterior motive is control of the economy. India Inc has to fight the growing influence of anti-business activists.

The author is a freelance journalist.

(Article first published in Business Standard)

IndiaCSR Whatsapp Channel

India CSR offers strategic corporate outreach opportunities to amplify your brand’s CSR, Sustainability, and ESG success stories.

📩 Contact us at: biz@indiacsr.in

Let’s collaborate to amplify your brand’s impact in the CSR and ESG ecosystem.

India CSR

India CSR

India CSR is the largest media on CSR and sustainability offering diverse content across multisectoral issues on business responsibility. It covers Sustainable Development, Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), Sustainability, and related issues in India. Founded in 2009, the organisation aspires to become a globally admired media that offers valuable information to its readers through responsible reporting.

Related Posts

India’s Veteran journalist Vinod Dua passes away
More

India’s Veteran journalist Vinod Dua passes away

4 years ago
373
India CSR
More

Republic or Democratic?

4 years ago
280
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

How can we conserve water amidst the Coronavirus crisis?

5 years ago
42
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Toyota Kirloskar Motor temporarily halts production at its Plant in Bidadi, Karnataka

5 years ago
57
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Govt. seeks public comments on Corporate Social Responsibility Policy (CSR) Amendment Rules, 2020

5 years ago
79
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

Govt to amend CSR rules under companies law, invites public comments

5 years ago
57
Dr. H. Chaturvedi on Stem Education in India at STEM – CSR Roundtable
Corporate Social Responsibility

MCA sanctions Prosecution in 366 cases given in violation of CSR Provisions

5 years ago
87
More

Schindler India launches an additional employee assistance program

5 years ago
32
More

NMDC Committed to fight COVID 19 for a safe and healthy India

5 years ago
12
Load More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

India CSR Awards India CSR Awards India CSR Awards
ADVERTISEMENT

LATEST NEWS

Bambrew Raises Rs 90 Cr to Drive Global Growth in Sustainable Materials

When to See a Spine Surgeon: Early Signs that require Attention

ध्यानगुरु रघुनाथ येमूल गुरुजी की दृष्टि से आषाढ़ की यात्राएँ : भक्ति, ऊर्जा और पर्यावरण का वैज्ञानिक और आध्यात्मिक समन्वय

CSR: Jindal Foundation Rolls Out ‘Hospital on Wheels’ to Boost Rural Healthcare in Jharkhand

Syngene International Transfers Rs 26 Lakhs to Unspent CSR Account for FY25

Muthoot Microfin Transfers Rs 2.58 Crore to Unspent CSR Account for FY25

HZL HZL HZL
ADVERTISEMENT

TOP NEWS

Mizoram Gets One of India’s Lowest CSR Fund Shares, Says CM Lalduhoma

When to See a Spine Surgeon: Early Signs that require Attention

Nilkamal CSR Spending Report of Rs 40.55 Lakhs for FY25

ITC Grows Plantation Area by 30% in FY25 to Boost Wood Sustainability

FedEx Fosters PRIDE and Purpose by Creating Equal Opportunities Across India

Muthoot Microfin CSR Spending Report of Rs 3.15 Crore for FY25

Load More

Advertisement

Image Slider
content writing services Guest Post Top 5 Reasons to have Sponsored Posts at India CSR – India’s Largest CSR Media stem learning R2V2 Technologies Private Limited

Interviews

Himanshu Nivsarkar, Senior Executive Vice President and Head of CSR & ESG at Kotak Mahindra Bank
Interviews

Driving Sustainable Impact: An Interview with Himanshu Nivsarkar, Kotak Mahindra Bank

by India CSR
May 22, 2025
140

By Rusen Kumar NEW DELHI (India CSR): Himanshu Nivsarkar, Senior Executive Vice President and Head of CSR & ESG at Kotak...

Read moreDetails
Balamurugan Thevar, CSR Head at Shriram Finance

Empowering Women Drivers: An Interview with Balamurugan Thevar, CSR Head at Shriram Finance

May 20, 2025
211
N E Sridhar, the Chief Sustainability Officer at Titan Company Ltd.

Empowering Rural Craft Entrepreneurs: An Interview with N E Sridhar, Titan Company

May 15, 2025
100
Geetaj Channana, the Head of Corporate Strategy at Vivo India

Empowering Young Innovators Across India: An Interview with Geetaj Channana, the Head of Corporate Strategy at Vivo India

April 25, 2025
54
Load More
Facebook Twitter Youtube LinkedIn Instagram
India CSR Logo

India CSR is the largest tech-led platform for information on CSR and sustainability in India offering diverse content across multisectoral issues. It covers Sustainable Development, Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), Sustainability, and related issues in India. Founded in 2009, the organisation aspires to become a globally admired media that offers valuable information to its readers through responsible reporting. To enjoy the premium services, we invite you to partner with us.

Follow us on social media:


Dear Valued Reader

India CSR is a free media platform that provides up-to-date information on CSR, Sustainability, ESG, and SDGs. They need reader support to continue delivering honest news. Donations of any amount are appreciated.

Help save India CSR.

Donate Now

donate at indiacsr

  • About India CSR
  • Team
  • India CSR Awards 2025
  • Partnership
  • Guest Posts
  • Services
  • Content Writing Services
  • Business Information
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Donate

Copyright © 2025 - India CSR | All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Art & Culture
    • CSR Leaders
    • Child Rights
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Around the World
    • Skill Development
    • Safety
    • Covid-19
    • Safe Food For All
  • Sustainability
    • Sustainability Dialogues
    • Sustainability Knowledge Series
    • Plastics
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • ESG
    • Circular Economy
    • BRSR
  • Corporate Governance
    • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Interviews
  • SDGs
    • No Poverty
    • Zero Hunger
    • Good Health & Well-Being
    • Quality Education
    • Gender Equality
    • Clean Water & Sanitation – SDG 6
    • Affordable & Clean Energy
    • Decent Work & Economic Growth
    • Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure
    • Reduced Inequalities
    • Sustainable Cities & Communities
    • Responsible Consumption & Production
    • Climate Action
    • Life Below Water
    • Life on Land
    • Peace, Justice & Strong Institutions
    • Partnerships for the Goals
  • Articles
  • Events
  • हिंदी
  • More
    • Business
    • Finance
    • Environment
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Around the World
    • Social Sector Leaders
    • Social Entrepreneurship
    • Trending News
      • Important Days
      • Great People
      • Product Review
      • International
      • Sports
      • Entertainment
    • Case Studies
    • Philanthropy
    • Biography
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Sports
    • Gaming
    • Knowledge
    • Home Improvement
    • Words Power
    • Chief Ministers

Copyright © 2025 - India CSR | All Rights Reserved

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.